Moving to Shrewsbury, PA: 2026 Living Guide

Shrewsbury is a small, established borough at the southern end of York County, a few minutes from the Maryland line and right on Interstate 83. Its Main Street follows the old York–Baltimore Turnpike, and the historic district along it includes log homes built before 1800. Step off Main Street and you find sycamore-lined residential streets, a borough park, and quick access to the Heritage Rail Trail and the farm markets that draw shoppers from both states.

Shrewsbury suits people who commute to Hunt Valley, Towson or Baltimore but want Pennsylvania living, families who want Southern York County schools, and empty nesters and retirees looking for a quiet, walkable borough. About four in five homes are owner-occupied, and the median age is over 50, so this is a settled community where people tend to stay.

Planning a move to Shrewsbury? Call our York PA & Maryland team at 717-844-5125 or get your price online.

Where Is Shrewsbury, PA?

Shrewsbury is a borough in York County, Pennsylvania, part of the York–Hanover metropolitan area. Its neighboring towns are New Freedom and Glen Rock, and the borough is surrounded by Shrewsbury Township, which lies along Interstate 83 between York to the north and Baltimore to the south. The borough covers about 1.8 square miles. I-83 Exit 4 is the Shrewsbury exit, and Route 851 runs west from it to one of the Heritage Rail Trail’s parking areas.

Approximate driving distances and times from Shrewsbury, based on OpenStreetMap routing (real times vary with traffic):

York (downtown): about 15 miles, roughly 25 minutes
Hunt Valley, MD: about 24 miles, roughly 30 to 35 minutes
Towson, MD: about 30 miles, roughly 40 minutes
Downtown Baltimore: about 39 miles, under an hour
Lancaster: about 40 miles, roughly an hour
Harrisburg: about 41 miles, roughly an hour
Harrisburg International Airport (MDT): about 46 miles
Baltimore/Washington International Airport (BWI): about 50 miles, a little over an hour
Washington, DC: about 75 miles

BWI and Harrisburg International are both within about an hour, so many residents choose based on the flight rather than the drive.

Shrewsbury Population & Demographics

Shrewsbury had 3,848 residents at the 2020 Census, and the Census Bureau estimated 4,014 as of July 1, 2025, a gain of more than 4% in five years. It is an older, well-off community. The median age is 51.9, more than a quarter of residents are 65 or older, and median household income is $101,833, well above the York County figure of $84,829.

Measure	Shrewsbury borough	York County	Data year
Population (2020 Census)	3,848	—	2020
Population estimate	4,014	473,197	July 1, 2025
Households (2020 Census)	1,545	—	2020
Median age	51.9	41.1	ACS 2020–2024
Persons under 18	16.4%	—	ACS 2020–2024
Persons 65 and over	26.3%	—	ACS 2020–2024
Median household income	$101,833	$84,829	ACS 2020–2024 (2024 dollars)
Per capita income	$49,872	$41,601	ACS 2020–2024 (2024 dollars)
Bachelor’s degree or higher (age 25+)	35.4%	27.6%	ACS 2020–2024
Owner-occupied housing rate	80.3%	76.3%	ACS 2020–2024
Poverty rate	4.2%	8.4%	ACS 2020–2024
Mean travel time to work	33.2 minutes	—	ACS 2020–2024

Sources: U.S. Census Bureau 2020 Census (via Wikipedia), Vintage 2025 population estimates, and Census Reporter (American Community Survey 5-year estimates).

Is Shrewsbury Safe?

We did not find a borough-level crime report we could cite, so we are not quoting a crime rate. The Census Bureau puts Shrewsbury’s poverty rate at 4.2%, about half the county rate, and most homes are owner-occupied, but that is no substitute for your own homework.

Police service comes from the Southern Regional Police Department, based at 49 East High Street in New Freedom. According to the borough, the department started on January 1, 1992, and serves Shrewsbury, Stewartstown and New Freedom, with part-time coverage for Glen Rock, Railroad and the Southern York County School District. The borough lists nine officers and one civilian employee, and the department runs community programs such as crime prevention and Block Watch. Before you buy, visit the street at night and on a weekend and talk to a neighbor or two.

Cost of Living in Shrewsbury

Shrewsbury costs more than the York County average, which reflects its location near the Maryland line, its schools and its well-kept older housing.

Home Prices

Zillow’s Home Value Index (smoothed and seasonally adjusted) puts the typical Shrewsbury home value at about $356,900 as of August 31, 2026, up 2.2% from a year earlier. That compares with about $311,100 for York County and about $290,400 for Pennsylvania on the same index.

The Census Bureau’s measure, the median value of owner-occupied homes, was $298,100 for 2020–2024. That is above York County ($248,600) and Pennsylvania ($254,500) but below the national figure of $332,700. The Census number reflects what owners reported over five years, while Zillow tracks current market values. According to the 2020 Census, the homeowner vacancy rate was just 1.3%, so there are rarely many houses on the market at once.

Rent

Rentals are limited. Median gross rent in Shrewsbury was $1,044 a month for 2020–2024, compared with $1,193 for York County, $1,209 for Pennsylvania and $1,413 for the United States. The 2020 Census counted a rental vacancy rate of 5.0%. Zillow does not publish a rent index for Shrewsbury itself, so check current listings in Shrewsbury, New Freedom and the surrounding townships to get a realistic picture of asking rents today.

Best Neighborhoods in Shrewsbury

Shrewsbury is small, but where you live in and around it changes your day-to-day life.

The Main Street Historic District

Shrewsbury was laid out in 1797 by Baltzer Faust along both sides of Joppa Road, later the York–Baltimore Turnpike and now Main Street. The Shrewsbury Historic District, listed on the National Register of Historic Places in 1984, includes 152 contributing buildings, a few of them log dwellings built before 1800, plus the 1853 Odd Fellows Hall and two Romanesque Revival churches. It suits buyers who love older homes and want to walk to local restaurants. Expect traffic on Main Street and older floor plans.

Residential Streets Near Sweeney Park

Sweeney Park is the borough’s main recreation space, with a pavilion residents can reserve from mid-May to mid-October. The residential blocks near it appeal to families and retirees who want a quieter street while still living inside the borough, with borough water, sewer and trash service. It is a good fit for anyone who wants small-town convenience without being right on Main Street.

Shrewsbury Township

Shrewsbury Township surrounds the borough and also wraps around Glen Rock, Railroad and New Freedom. It had 6,657 residents at the 2020 Census and covers about 29 square miles along I-83. Buyers who want acreage, newer homes or more room for garages and outbuildings often look here while keeping Southern York County schools. Always confirm whether an address is in the borough or the township, because services, taxes and permits differ.

Weather & Climate

Shrewsbury has four distinct seasons. NOAA’s 1991–2020 normals for York, about 15 miles north and published on Wikipedia, show a January average high of 41.2°F with lows around 21.3°F, and a July average high of 87.7°F with lows around 63.1°F. York averages about 46 inches of precipitation and 24.6 inches of snow a year, with January (8.5 inches) and February (8.2 inches) the snowiest months.

For moving, late April through early June and September through October are usually the most comfortable. Summer is popular with families but hot and humid. In winter, the borough declares snow emergencies that ban parking on snow emergency routes and local streets, which matters if you were counting on curb space for a truck.

Things to Do in Shrewsbury

Heritage Rail Trail County Park

York County’s Heritage Rail Trail runs 27 miles from the Mason-Dixon Line just south of New Freedom through Glen Rock, Hanover Junction and Seven Valleys to the Colonial Courthouse in York, according to York County Parks. From I-83 Exit 4, the county’s directions send you west on Route 851 about 3 miles to a trail parking area. Class 1 pedal-assist e-bikes are allowed on this trail, the only county park where they are.

Northern Central Railway

Next door in New Freedom, the Northern Central Railway runs excursion trains along the tracks beside the rail trail between New Freedom and Seven Valleys. York County Parks reminds trail users that the tracks are active and a train can come by at any time, which is part of the fun on a weekend walk.

The Markets at Shrewsbury

Just outside the borough, with a Glen Rock mailing address, the Markets at Shrewsbury sells handcrafted Amish and artisan goods and hosts local vendors. It is open Thursday 9 a.m. to 5 p.m., Friday 9 a.m. to 6 p.m. and Saturday 8 a.m. to 4 p.m., and it runs seasonal events such as cruise nights. It is an easy place to stock a new kitchen with meats, cheeses and baked goods.

Sweeney Park

The borough describes Sweeney Park as a gift from Shrewsbury’s citizens to themselves, and it is the town’s main recreation space. Its pavilion can be rented by the day from mid-May to mid-October at a lower rate for borough residents. The park closes at dusk and does not allow alcohol.

Lake Redman and Antiques

Explore York points visitors from Shrewsbury to Lake Redman at William H. Kain County Park and to the Shrewsbury Antique Center, with more than 10,000 square feet of antiques and collectibles. York County manages about 4,500 acres of public park land in all.

Where to Eat in Shrewsbury

J&B’s Grill

J&B’s Grill, at 14 North Main Street, serves diner-style breakfast and lunch, plus dinner on some evenings, in an old house with several small dining rooms. It opens at 8 a.m. most days, so it is a good place to feed the family on the morning of a move. Check current hours, because they vary by day.

Vincent’s Deli

Vincent’s Deli, at 551 South Main Street, is an Italian restaurant and deli with online ordering and catering. Its catering menu is an easy way to feed the friends and family helping you unpack.

New China Restaurant

New China, at 565 South Main Street, is a takeout spot open for lunch and into the evening, past 9 p.m. It is a dependable choice for the first night in a new house when the kitchen is still in boxes.

Jobs & Economy

Most Shrewsbury residents commute. The average travel time to work is 33.2 minutes, which reflects how many people drive I-83 south to jobs in Hunt Valley, Towson and Baltimore or north to York and Harrisburg. Living in Pennsylvania while working in Maryland is common here, so ask a tax professional how that affects your withholding.

York County’s largest employers, according to the Pennsylvania Department of Labor & Industry’s list for the first quarter of 2026, include York Hospital, the federal government, Amazon, WellSpan Health, Walmart, York County government, Giant Food Stores, BAE Systems, Kinsley Construction and Utz Quality Foods.

Schools in Shrewsbury

Shrewsbury is part of the Southern York County School District, which covers about 68 square miles and serves Codorus Township, Glen Rock, Railroad, New Freedom, Shrewsbury Township, Shrewsbury Borough and part of Hopewell Township. The district runs five schools: Friendship Elementary, Shrewsbury Elementary, Southern Elementary, Southern Middle School and Susquehannock High School, the district’s only high school. High school students can also choose the York County School of Technology for construction and mechanical trades.

The Paul Smith Library of Southern York County is in Shrewsbury, and families also look at York-area private schools and colleges such as York College of Pennsylvania, about 25 minutes north. Confirm school assignments for a specific address with the district before you buy.

Shrewsbury Quick Facts

County	York County
ZIP code	17361
Area codes	717 and 223 (overlay; 10-digit dialing)
Area	About 1.8 square miles
Incorporated	August 9, 1834
Main highway	Interstate 83 (Exit 4, Shrewsbury)
Borough office	35 West Railroad Avenue
Nearest airports	Harrisburg International (about 46 miles); BWI (about 50 miles)
Public school district	Southern York County School District
Police	Southern Regional Police Department
Trash hauler	Penn Waste

Moving to Shrewsbury: Tips From Our Crew

Watch for snow emergencies. Under the borough’s snow emergency ordinance, parking is banned on snow emergency routes and local streets during declared emergencies. Sidewalks must be cleared within 24 hours of a snowfall. For a winter move, keep a backup date and plan where the truck can legally park.
Time I-83 around rush hour. If you are coming up from Baltimore County, the Hunt Valley and Towson stretch of I-83 is busiest at commute times. A mid-morning start usually gets the truck to Exit 4 faster.
Know your state paperwork. Moving from Maryland to Pennsylvania means a new driver’s license, vehicle registration and local earned income tax setup. Start the list early so it does not pile up after moving day.
Plan for older homes on Main Street. Historic district homes, some dating to before 1800, can have narrow stairs, low doorways and small landings. Measure your largest pieces so we can plan disassembly and protection.
Recycle electronics the right way. Under Pennsylvania’s Act 108, the borough’s hauler will not take TVs, computers and similar devices. The York County Solid Waste Authority accepts them free at its Flour Mill Road facility on weekdays from 8 a.m. to 4 p.m. and Saturday mornings. For everything else you do not want to move, try our junk removal service.
Downsizing? Many Shrewsbury moves are empty nesters moving to a smaller home. Our storage and packing services can help you sort what goes, what stays and what waits.

Frequently Asked Questions About Moving to Shrewsbury

How much do movers cost in Shrewsbury, PA?

It depends on the size of your home, the distance, stairs, packing and your date. A local move within southern York County is priced differently from a move up from Baltimore County or out of state. The fastest way to a real number is a free quote. Call 717-844-5125 and an owner will call you back within 15 minutes between 8 a.m. and 8 p.m.

How far is Shrewsbury from Baltimore?

Downtown Baltimore is about 39 miles away by road, usually under an hour outside of rush hour. Hunt Valley is about 24 miles and Towson about 30 miles down I-83, which is why so many Shrewsbury residents commute into Baltimore County.

Is Shrewsbury a good place to retire?

Many people think so. More than a quarter of residents are 65 or older, the borough is small and walkable along Main Street, and the Heritage Rail Trail, farm markets and parks are close by. It is also close to Maryland for family visits. Housing costs are above the York County average, so plan your budget accordingly.

What school district serves Shrewsbury?

The Southern York County School District. It serves Shrewsbury Borough and Shrewsbury Township along with New Freedom, Glen Rock, Railroad, Codorus Township and part of Hopewell Township. Students attend one of three elementary schools, Southern Middle School and Susquehannock High School.

Do you handle moves between Maryland and Shrewsbury?

Yes. Our York PA & Maryland office handles moves on both sides of the state line, plus long-distance moves. For long-distance jobs you get a binding estimate, your own dedicated truck, the same W-2 crew from door to door and a guaranteed delivery date. Military families get 5% off through our military moves program.

Move to Shrewsbury With A & M Friendly Movers

A & M Friendly Movers has been family owned since 2015, and our owners, Matthew Treharn and Amber Hallaman, stand behind every job. Our crews are background-checked, drug-tested W-2 employees, never subcontractors. With our Owner’s Promise, you talk to an owner, not a call center. If anything is damaged, an owner calls you the same day, and claims are resolved in 60 to 90 days. We have 850+ Google reviews across our five locations, and you can read them here.

From historic homes on Main Street to farmhouses in Shrewsbury Township, our Shrewsbury movers handle local moves, long-distance moves, packing, storage and piano and safe moving. Call our York PA & Maryland team at 717-844-5125 or visit the Shrewsbury moving page.

Get My Price

Moving to Shrewsbury, PA: Living in Shrewsbury Guide